By Colonel Ann Wright, Retired
t r u t h o u t | Guest Contributor
Saturday 23 December 2006
On January 11, 2002, the first detainees from Afghanistan arrived at
the prison in the US Naval Base, Guantanamo, Cuba. In the succeeding
five years, Guantanamo has symbolized to the world the Bush
administration's abandonment of international and domestic law, and the
development of a policy of inhumane treatment and use of torture. These
claims have been linked to military and CIA operations in Afghanistan,
Iraq and in an unknown number of secret prisons.
11, 2002. After five years, no Guantanamo detainee has been convicted of
a criminal offense. According to an American Forces Information Service
News article dated October 17, 2006, "Bush Says Military Commissions Act
Will Bring Justice," the majority of the detainees held in Guantanamo
will not face military commissions. "Only detainees who will be charged
with law-of-war violations and other grave offenses - about 75
detainees, officials estimated - will be subject to the commissions."
So what has happened to the other 700 detainees during these five
years - those who will not be prosecuted by military commissions?
Finally, after more than two years of detention, between August 2004
and March 2005, Combatant Status Review Tribunals (CSRT), composed of
three US military officers, reviewed the cases of 558 detainees.
However, the detainees had no access to lawyers or to secret evidence
used by the CSRT. The CSRT could use coerced evidence. The CSRTs judged
520 detainees to be "enemy combatants."
What is an enemy combatant? The general definition of an enemy
combatant is "a person engaged in hostilities against the United States
or its coalition partners during an armed conflict." But a September 5,
2006, Department of Defense directive on the Detainee Program added
another sentence to the definition of unlawful combatant: "For the
purposes of the war on terrorism, the term Unlawful Enemy Combatant is
defined to include, but is not limited to, an individual who is or was
part of or supporting Taliban or al Qaeda forces or associated forces
that are engaged in hostilities against the United States or its
According to Amnesty International, in an analysis of 500 detainees,
a remarkably low number, only 5 percent, or about 25 detainees, were
captured by US forces. Eighty-six percent, or about 430 detainees, were
arrested by Pakistani forces or the Afghan Northern Alliance and turned
over to US custody - often for a reward of thousands of dollars. The
other 9 percent are not discussed in the Amnesty report. Many were sold
to the United States to even scores or just for the money. Anyone living
in Afghanistan - young or old - was fair game for sale to US forces. The
oldest detainee shipped to Guantanamo was 75 and the youngest 10.
It is an understatement to say that the majority of those sent to
Guantanamo were sent due to poor interrogation and investigation by US
forces and the CIA during their detention in Afghanistan. Once at
Guantanamo, they remained for years because of pressure for
interrogation "results" from the civilian political leadership at the
Department of Defense, the Central Intelligence Agency and the White House.
As of December 18, 2006, almost half - about 379 of the 775
detainees - have been released after years in prison. They were sent
home without being charged with a crime or being told why they had been
detained. About 396 detainees from 35 countries are still held at
Guantanamo; this includes 14 detainees who were transferred there in
September 2006 after being held incommunicado in secret CIA prisons for
up to four and a half years. (When President Bush signed the Military
Commissions Act (MCA) into law, he said that the MCA authorizes the CIA
secret-prison program to continue. He also said that the 14 cannot
reveal to their lawyers or the International Committee of the Red Cross
the location of the detention facilities, conditions of confinement, and
Sixteen detainees from Saudi Arabia were released on December 14,
2006, after King Abdullah summoned Vice President Cheney to Saudi Arabia
and took him to the woodshed over the plight of Sunnis if the United
States withdraws from Iraq. Another 75 Saudis remain in Guantanamo. More
detainees were released on December 17, according to a Department of
Defense news release with the same date: Seven detainees were
transferred to Afghanistan; six were returned to Yemen; three went to
Kazakhstan; one went to Libya, and one to Bangladesh. This resulted in
thirty-four detainees being released in three days. The news release
said that 114 detainees have been released in 2006 and 85 detainees,
whom the US government has determined are eligible for transfer or
release, are still being held at Guantanamo.
Seventeen detainees were under 18 years old when they were taken to
Guantanamo. The youngest were 10, 12, and 13 when they were "captured."
At the end of 2006, four of these juveniles still are detained. They
have spent one-fourth of their lives in Guantanamo. There was a fifth,
but he was one of three detainees who committed suicide in June 2006.
More than 40 detainees have attempted suicide, and up to 200 detainees
have staged hunger strikes to protest the conditions of detention.
Incredibly, at the end of five years of being in the world's
human-rights doghouse, the US Congress in October 2006 again trusted and
complied with President Bush's wishes and passed the Military
Commissions Act (MCA). The MCA denies detainees habeas corpus (the right
to challenge the lawfulness or conditions of detention); denies the
presumption of innocence; denies the right to trial within a reasonable
time; denies the right to a lawyer of choice, and denies the right to
challenge and present evidence. The MCA allows the admission of evidence
coerced by cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
While co-authoring memos on torture, presidential legal advisor
Alberto Gonzales, now attorney general, advised President Bush in
January 2002 that a benefit of not applying the Geneva Conventions to
detainees coming from Afghanistan, and imprisoning the detainees outside
the United States, would be to make it more difficult to prosecute US
personnel under the US War Crimes Act. The administration's "gloves off"
attitude toward interrogations resulted in inhumane treatment in Bagram,
Kandahar, and other prisons in Afghanistan, and later in Guantanamo.
That abusive environment led to painful incidents at Abu Ghraib, Iraq,
as Guantanamo prison commander Major General Geoffrey Miller went to
Iraq to teach more-aggressive techniques to the interrogators. Gonzalez
continued to make it harder to prosecute US personnel for prisoner abuse
under the War Crimes Act by convincing Congress - through the Military
Commissions Act - to provide a free pass for criminal acts dealing with
detainees if the acts were committed before December 31, 2005.
As a retired US Army colonel with 29 years of service on active duty
and in the US Army Reserves, and as a US diplomat for 16 years, I firmly
believe that there must be accountability and responsibility for
criminal actions that we know have occurred - whether the perpetrators
are in the Pentagon, the CIA, the Justice Department, or the White
House. Speaking as a military officer, I believe our military is not
served well by escaping responsibility for criminal acts. Our soldiers
and officers are taught what behavior is legal and what is not. I would
think that the same distinction also is taught to CIA personnel. When
the Bush administration and Congress retroactively protect those who
knowing commit criminal acts, they undermine the "order and discipline"
of the military and of the CIA. Ultimately this undercuts the
foundations of our rule of law.
I firmly believe that to regain some respect in the international
community, for the sake of our national spirit and soul, and for the
integrity of the US military, the prison in Guantanamo must be closed.
The US military must be removed from adjudicating "enemy combatants"
cases. Instead, I believe the federal courts must administer the laws of
the United States against persons charged with "terrorist" crimes, as
the courts have done in the past. For the United States to ever hope to
salvage some modicum of its stature in the area of human rights, the
legal process for those accused of criminal terrorist acts must be
transparent and fair. The "Guantanamo process" is neither. I call on the
new Congress to acknowledge the capabilities and history of our civilian
legal system, to abolish the Military Commissions Act, to designate the
federal courts to hear the cases, and to close Guantanamo.
On January 11, 2007, the fifth year that detainees from Afghanistan
have been in Guantanamo, organizations all over the world will call for
Guantanamo to be closed. For the sake of our integrity and conscience,
each one of us must take action: Organize vigils, show the movie "The
Road to Guantanamo" or have readings of /"Guantanamo: Honor Bound to
Defend Freedom"/ (www.bordc.org <http://www.bordc.org/>).
Act on January 11 to end torture, stop violations of international
law, and CLOSE GUANTANAMO! (Check www.witnesstorture.org
<http://www.witnesstorture.org/> for events.)
/Colonel Ann Wright, retired, spent 29 years in the Army and Army
Reserves and 16 years as a US diplomat serving in Nicaragua, Grenada,
Somalia, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Sierra Leone, Micronesia, Afghanistan,
and Mongolia. She resigned from the US Department of State in March 2003
in opposition to the war on Iraq./
* The world is too much with us Late and soon
Getting and spending, we lay waste our powers
Little we see in nature, that is ours
We have given our hearts away a sordid boon
-- Wisdom from the poet Wordsworth